• Superpanel Blog
  • Posts
  • How Lawfty scaled personal injury intake with an AI call center

How Lawfty scaled personal injury intake with an AI call center

Lawfty used Superpanel's platform to run AI intake across 13 case types and 100+ partner firms, and now passes about 20% more cases per inquiry.

Interested in Superpanel’s AI agents could work for your business? Let’s discuss your use case.

The challenge: could AI handle intake this complex?

Lawfty generates personal injury cases for law firms across the country. It runs the advertising, qualifies every caller, and hands viable cases to partner firms, answering each call as the firm behind that campaign.

In mid-2025, several of Lawfty’s marketing channels began gaining traction at once, and it was clear lead volume would soon outpace its intake team. Hiring alone wouldn’t close the gap: a new specialist needs 4 to 6 weeks to get on the phones and about six months to master the work. To scale the way it wanted, Lawfty knew it needed a different approach and began exploring an AI call center for legal intake.

The big question was whether AI could do the job reliably. Lawfty manages intake for 13 case types across more than 100 partner firms covering all 50 states. Each case type has its own rules on injury, liability, prior representation, and filing deadlines, and those deadlines vary by state. A wrong call means a lost case or a bad referral to a partner firm.

"There was a major concern on my part around false negatives. Our business is hyper-sensitive to conversion loss, so was it going to be able to qualify correctly? Was it going to be able to classify correctly?"

Andrew Stein, COO, Lawfty

The approach: built for the complexity, step by step

Lawfty had engineers who could have built its own AI agents, but the complexity of its intake is the reason it didn't. Lawfty chose Superpanel, a platform that pairs AI reasoning with deterministic qualification rules, tracks each caller's journey, and writes every outcome back to the systems Lawfty already runs on.

"This is a very fast-moving technology. And it is complicated. It involves the integration of multiple technologies. And so to get it right, you need somebody that's going to be focused exclusively on that, and so that was the basis of our decision [to go with Superpanel]."

Todd Richheimer, CEO, Lawfty

Choosing a platform didn't make the work easy. Lawfty spent months configuring the AI intake agent with Superpanel's team of solution consultants, with one goal: send partner firms the best, most qualified cases. Handling that complexity while giving callers a better experience came down to three parts.

1. Start with the smallest piece worth doing, and test it

Lawfty started by replacing its press-1 phone menu with an AI intake agent built on Superpanel's platform, splitting inbound calls with its existing IVR for about five months. The old menu asked one yes-or-no question about injury. Lawfty's new AI intake agent let callers describe what happened in their own words, then asked follow-up questions, and ended up identifying more real injury cases.

The test gave Lawfty the confidence to go further. "We saw really promising results, which was a good motivation for us to keep going," said Elizabeth Rotunno, Lawfty's Director of Engineering. From there, Lawfty rolled out the AI intake agent one case type at a time. For each new case type, it measured the AI intake agent's performance against its existing intake flow before moving on.

2. Turn the business logic into decisions the AI intake agent can follow

Lawfty's qualification rules lived in years of training, specialist experience, and its CRM. Lawfty spelled out what each CRM field meant to the business, configured its definitions down to the edge cases, and gave the AI intake agent full decision trees, not general guidance. Complex qualification rules its engineers had wanted to build for a long time went live on the platform quickly.

3. Connect the whole stack, and keep the data flowing

Lawfty connected Superpanel's platform to its phone system, web forms and SMS, its in-house CRM, its intake team through warm transfers with a case summary, and a referral partner for callers Lawfty can't help.

Clean data flow mattered because Lawfty runs on data. Its analytics team tracks every inquiry from first call to settlement, and at Lawfty's volume, a small error can repeat across hundreds of calls before anyone notices. Because the AI intake agent asks every caller the same questions the same way and writes every outcome back, Lawfty can monitor its performance closely and catch problems fast.

The result: about 20% more cases passed per inquiry

The groundwork paid off in Lawfty's own numbers. In an A/B test on direct inbound calls from late June to mid-October, Lawfty passed 12.7% of inquiries to partner firms within 72 hours with the AI intake agent, compared with 10.5% with its internal flow. That's about 1.2x as many cases per inquiry, and the AI intake agent came out ahead in all but one week of the test.

Weekly pass rate per inquiry (passed to a partner firm within 72 hours) in Lawfty's direct inbound call test. Source: Lawfty analytics.

On web form follow-up, the gap was wide enough that Lawfty stopped testing early and moved all of it to Superpanel within two weeks.

"We didn't even wait for it to get to statistical significance, because it was such a benefit to our business and to our bottom line that we just made the switch as soon as we saw how big the delta was."

Ken Rotunno, Director of Analytics, Lawfty

Today, nearly all of Lawfty's inbound traffic reaches the AI intake agent first.

What Lawfty can do now that intake is no longer a constraint

Intake no longer sets the pace of Lawfty's growth. With the AI intake agent answering first, Lawfty runs the same careful intake on every call, and that consistency pays off for its callers, its partner firms, and its business.

  • Callers get an answer, and room to tell their story. Before, calls that came in when fewer than two specialists were free went to an overflow call center that answered 80% to 85% of them. Now every call is answered, callers describe what happened in their own words, and anyone who asks for a person goes straight to Lawfty's team.

  • Partner firms get consistent, well-qualified cases. Every inquiry is vetted against the same rules, so a case's label means the same thing no matter who handled it. Lawfty tunes those rules toward cases firms want to sign, not just more cases.

  • Marketing can scale with confidence. Lawfty's operations team considers intake capacity solved, whether volume stays where it is or grows 3x or 10x. Consistent data from every call also shows which channels produce cases that sign and settle.

  • The team works on what moves the business. The AI intake agent screens out disqualified inquiries, about 30% of the total, before they reach Lawfty's specialists, and saves them a couple of minutes on each call they do take. [confirm: minutes saved] Andrew's operations team, which spent 60% to 70% of its time on staffing, now has time for projects that always had to wait behind staffing: partner firm integrations, faster onboarding for new firms, and better pipeline data.

"If Marissa, our Chief Marketing Officer, comes to me and says, 'We've got this idea, we've tested it, it's gonna be really big. Are we prepared to handle X percentage more leads by two weeks from now?' I don't have to scramble to plug that hole. I know it's there."

Andrew Stein, COO, Lawfty

What's next: pushing the future of work further together

Lawfty's rollout isn't finished, and the team is candid that challenges remain. Three are top of mind: keeping every decision accurate as volume grows, deciding where a person adds the most value as more partner firms adopt AI intake, and helping specialists work alongside the AI intake agent. Having already run intake this complex on Superpanel's platform at scale, Lawfty is confident it can keep pushing the frontier of what AI intake can handle. The goal stays the same: a better experience for every caller, and the best cases for every partner firm.

See what this looks like for your firm

If you run high-volume intake and want to grow without trading away the client experience, let’s chat.